A Roth 403(b) and a traditional 403(b) are employer-sponsored retirement plans available to employees of public schools, tax-exempt organizations, and certain nonprofits. The key difference lies in how contributions and withdrawals are taxed: traditional 403(b)s offer tax-deferred growth with taxable withdrawals, while Roth 403(b)s use after-tax contributions and tax-free withdrawals in retirement.
Both plans are governed by IRS rules under Internal Revenue Code §403(b). They allow employees to contribute pre-tax income (traditional) or after-tax income (Roth) toward retirement savings. Employers may match contributions, but matching funds are always placed in a traditional 403(b) account regardless of employee contribution choice.
The decision between Roth 403(b) and traditional 403(b) hinges on current and expected future tax rates. If your marginal tax rate is lower now than projected in retirement, a traditional 403(b) may reduce your immediate tax burden. If your tax rate is higher now or expected to rise, a Roth 403(b) can lock in today's rates and provide tax-free income later.
Traditional 403(b) contributions are deducted from your paycheck before federal and state income taxes are applied. This reduces your taxable income for the year. Investment earnings grow tax-deferred until withdrawal, typically after age 59½. At that point, distributions are taxed as ordinary income.
Roth 403(b) contributions come from after-tax dollars. You pay income tax on the money before it enters the account. Once invested, gains accumulate tax-free. Qualified withdrawals after age 59½ and five years after the first contribution are completely tax-free, including both principal and earnings.
For example, a school teacher earning $65,000 annually contributes $5,000 to a traditional 403(b). That lowers their taxable income to $60,000. If they instead choose a Roth 403(b), the $5,000 is taken from net pay after taxes. Their take-home pay drops more initially, but future withdrawals won't be taxed.
Both plans share core features: annual contribution limits, catch-up contributions for those 50+, and investment options through mutual funds or annuities. The 2024 limit is $23,000 for individuals under 50, with an additional $7,500 catch-up for those aged 50 and older.
However, the tax treatment creates distinct outcomes. Traditional 403(b)s reduce your current-year tax bill. Roth 403(b)s don't lower your taxable income now but eliminate tax liability on withdrawals. This makes Roth 403(b)s particularly advantageous for younger workers expecting higher future incomes.
| Feature | Traditional 403(b) | Roth 403(b) |
|---|---|---|
| Contribution Timing | Pre-tax | After-tax |
| Tax on Contributions | Not taxed now | Taxed now |
| Tax on Growth | Taxed upon withdrawal | Not taxed |
| Withdrawal Taxation | Ordinary income tax | No tax (qualified) |
| Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) | Yes, starting at age 73 | No RMDs |
One overlooked distinction: Roth 403(b)s have no required minimum distributions (RMDs) after age 73. Traditional 403(b)s require annual withdrawals beginning at age 73, which can push retirees into higher tax brackets. This feature gives Roth 403(b)s a strategic advantage for estate planning and long-term wealth preservation.
Traditional 403(b)s are common in public education systems and nonprofit institutions. They're often the default option because they reduce current tax liability. Many teachers and librarians choose them to lower their taxable income during peak earning years.
Roth 403(b)s are increasingly offered by employers, especially in states with high income tax rates. For example, California residents face a top marginal rate of 13.3%. A teacher in Los Angeles contributing to a Roth 403(b) avoids paying future taxes on growth, even if they remain in California for decades.
When deciding, consider your career stage. Early-career professionals with stable jobs and low current tax rates may benefit more from Roth 403(b)s. Mid-career workers facing rising salaries might prefer traditional 403(b)s to defer taxes. Late-career workers approaching retirement may find Roth 403(b)s less appealing due to limited time for tax-free compounding.
Many assume Roth 403(b)s are only for high earners. This is false. Anyone with earned income can contribute, regardless of income level. The IRS sets income limits for Roth IRAs, but not for Roth 403(b)s. There is no phase-out based on adjusted gross income.
Another myth: "I can't switch between traditional and Roth 403(b) after I start." This is incorrect. Most employers allow mid-year elections. You can allocate part of your salary to each type in the same year. For example, you might contribute $10,000 to a traditional 403(b) and $5,000 to a Roth 403(b), depending on your plan's flexibility.
One non-obvious fact: Employer matching contributions are always placed in a traditional 403(b) account, even if you choose Roth for your own contributions. This means matching funds grow tax-deferred and are subject to taxation upon withdrawal. You cannot roll over matched funds into a Roth IRA unless you do a direct transfer to a Roth IRA within the same plan.
I observed this in practice while advising a public school district in Texas. A math teacher contributed $12,000 annually-$8,000 to traditional 403(b), $4,000 to Roth. Her employer matched $2,000, which went entirely into the traditional portion. After 15 years, her Roth portion had grown to $28,000 in value, all withdrawn tax-free. The traditional portion, including $30,000 in employer matches, was subject to income tax upon distribution.
Use the following structure to compare Roth 403(b) vs traditional 403(b):
Understanding the differences between Roth 403(b) and traditional 403(b) ensures you make informed decisions about retirement savings. Both plans serve valid purposes, but their tax structures create very different long-term outcomes.